"Surgeons at Nicosia State Hospital, are struggling with a case of kidney transplantation. Ali, a 17 year old, passionately wants to donate a kidney to his identical twin, Max. The surgeons are hesitating, questioning whether by subjecting Ali to surgery they would be providing him with any benefit. They call the twins’ parents in, to discuss the case. Surgeons discover that one of the parents support Ali’s "consent" to donate his kidney to save his brother and the other parent object to Ali’s "choice".What are the ethical considerations in the above case?"
Answers
The case at Nicosia State Hospital raises complex ethical considerations. On one hand, the surgeons are faced with the dilemma of potentially subjecting Ali to surgery without direct medical benefit, as they question whether he gains any advantage from the procedure. This poses the ethical question of avoiding harm to Ali while striving to ensure his autonomy and well-being. Additionally, the situation highlights the balance between individual autonomy and familial decision-making, as Ali's parents hold differing views on his decision to donate a kidney. The disagreement reflects the broader tension between respecting individual choices and prioritizing collective family values. Ethical deliberations in this case would involve weighing the potential benefits to Max against the potential risks to Ali, while also considering cultural and familial dynamics in the decision-making process.
Final answer:
The ethical considerations in the case of kidney transplantation between identical twins include autonomy, beneficence, and justice. Surgeons need to consider Ali's right to make decisions about his own body (autonomy), determine if the transplantation would truly benefit Max and if the risks to Ali are justified (beneficence), and ensure a fair decision that takes into account the parents' differing opinions (justice).
Explanation:
In the case of kidney transplantation between identical twins, there are several ethical considerations that need to be taken into account. One of the main considerations is the principle of autonomy, which refers to an individual's right to make decisions about their own body. In this case, Ali, a 17-year-old twin, passionately wants to donate his kidney to his identical twin, Max. However, the surgeons are hesitating because they are unsure if Ali would benefit from the surgery.
Another ethical consideration is the principle of beneficence, which involves promoting the well-being of others. The surgeons need to determine if the kidney transplantation would truly benefit Max and if the risks to Ali are justified. They need to weigh the potential benefits to Max against the potential risks to Ali's health and well-being.
Additionally, the principle of justice should be considered. Justice involves fairness and equality. The surgeons need to ensure that the decision made is fair to both Ali and Max, as well as taking into account the parents' differing opinions. They need to consider the potential impact on Ali's future health and well-being, as well as the potential impact on Max's quality of life if he does not receive a kidney transplant.
Overall, the ethical considerations in this case revolve around autonomy, beneficence, and justice. The surgeons must carefully weigh the potential benefits and risks, consider the twins' wishes, and make a decision that is fair and in the best interest of both individuals.
Learn more about ethical considerations in a case of kidney transplantation between identical twins here:
#SPJ14
Related Questions
The cytoplasm in a cell carries out a function similair to which human system
The enzymatic hydrolysis of sucrose by the enzyme sucrase will result in the formation of its two monosaccharide components, glucose and fructose, as seen in the model above. The activity of an enzyme is affected by many factors including temperature and pH. Each enzyme has an optimum temperature and pH at which its reaction rate is fastest. The optimum pH range for sucrase activity is 4 - 8.Imagine the pH of the environment in which the hydrolysis of sucrose is to occur has dropped to 2. How will this drop in pH influence point D in the model?A)The enzyme (B) will allow less of the substrate (A) to move into the active site (C). B)More of the substrate (A) will fit into the active site (C), so more products will be produced. C)The substrate (A) will no longer fit into the active site (C) because the enzyme has changed shape. D)There will be no change to the components of point D with a drop in pH; only temperature can denature the enzyme.
What is the difference between static and current electricity? give an example of each
A lava field could someday be a diverse temperate forest! True False
Answers
Answers
Bases A and T and C and G
b. Cretaceous
c.Triassic
d. Jurassic
Answers
B. f(x) = 5000(0.6)x, with a vertical asymptote of x = 0
C. f(x) = 5000(1.4)x, with a horizontal asymptote of y = 0
D. f(x) = 5000(1.6)x, with a vertical asymptote of x = 0
Answers
Answer:
The correct option is A.
Step by step explanation:
The exponential function is defined as
Where, a is initial value and b is growth factor or decay factor.
The initial population of bacteria is 5000.
After each day of treatment, 40% of the sample remains alive. It means the growth factor or decay factor is
Therefore the required function is
The horizontal asymptote is y=0 because
Therefore option A is correct.
unproductive wastelands
b.
valuable fish habitats
c.
an erosion preventing habitat
d.
pollution filters
Answers
Answers
Answer:
Heart disease is the leading cause of the death in the United States. It is also a major cause of disability. There are many things that can raise your risk for heart disease. They are called risk factors. These ahould be considered as starters for a teaching plan to adults with no medical background, the risk factors that can be changed and the ones that cannot.
- Gender
- Age
- Family History
- Race or ethnicity
The factor above are considered as risk that cannot be changed, there are some risks that women and men have differently for example, progesterone protects women from heart diseases but if the patient develops diabetes women are mostly likely to have a heart disease. Also age is factor that can't be changed or controled men over 45 are more likely to have a heart disease and women over 55 are more likely to have a heart disease.
Even though there are some factor that can be controlled by taking care of yor health, for example; Controlling yor blood pressure, have a healthy diet with lots of vegetables and fruits, following the food pyramid for a balanced meal everyday, practice exercise and avoid sedentarism, stop smoking it will only increase your blood pressure, sleep well, you should be sleeping from 7 to 9 hours a day, control your weight, the fat in your blood can cover your veins and arteries, mainly the coronary ones which are in charge of supplying oxygen-rich blood to the heart. Finally you can also limit and control the amount of alcohol you ingest and the amount of stress you deal everyday.
These are basic terms to educate adults with no health backgrounf about prevention of heart diseases.